I would choose Plymouth because first they started off good. Another great reason is they were friends with the Indians.In Jamestown it was hard to get food,but in plymouth they didn’t need to worry. They didn’t come to get rich,they came to be free and worship.They also had men,women,and children.They started to grow and became the largest colony there.It would be very cool to have the first Thanksgiving with them.They had a very good relationship with the Indians,so they threw a big celebration.They only had one bad winter comparing to Jamestown who had bad days all the time.Also,the People there had colorful clothing,and came for freedom.These are all of my reasons to choose Plymouth.